If you find your mascara smudging underneath your eyes throughout the day, you're not alone. Many of us have experienced this frustrating makeup mishap. But fear not, there are solutions to keep your mascara in place without resorting to waterproof formulas that may irritate your eyes.

"You are probably using crappy mascara."

First things first, evaluate the mascara you're using. If it's prone to smudging, it might be time to switch to a higher quality product. Look for mascaras labeled hypoallergenic, as they are less likely to cause irritation or smudging.

"I could suggest waterproof but that makes my eyes burn." 

While waterproof mascara is known for its smudge-proof properties, it can be harsh on sensitive eyes and difficult to remove. If waterproof formulas cause discomfort, consider hypoallergenic alternatives instead.

“If you are not allergic then try it.”

If you're not allergic to waterproof mascara and are willing to give it a try, it may be worth testing to see if it helps prevent smudging. Just be sure to remove it gently at the end of the day to avoid damaging your lashes.

"You may be able to use the mascara's that have a lengthener with it." (Author Unknown)

Another trick to prevent mascara smudging is to use a lengthening mascara with a separate primer. Applying the primer first can create a base for the mascara to adhere to, helping it last longer without smudging.

“Put it on under the mascara itself. It may have a quality that allows the mascara last longer.”

By applying the lengthening primer before your regular mascara, you can enhance its longevity and reduce the chances of smudging throughout the day.

“Or call a department store, the counter help may be able to recommend a mascara that will last.”

If you're unsure which mascara to try, consider seeking advice from beauty professionals at department store makeup counters. They can recommend products tailored to your needs and preferences.

“If you call a salon, they may want you to come into the salon and pay for the service of telling you what to use.”

While some salons may offer makeup consultations for a fee, calling a department store for advice can save you time and money.

“I would call the department store. Kohl's or Macy's would be a good place to start.”

Department stores like Kohl's or Macy's often carry a wide range of mascara brands and can provide expert recommendations based on your specific requirements.

"At least if you call them you won't waste your time and money going up there for nothing."

By reaching out to department store beauty advisors over the phone, you can gather valuable information without the need to visit the store in person.